|
From: "PUBYAC: PUBlic librarians serving Young Adults and Children"
< pubyac@prairienet.org>
To: "PUBYAC: PUBlic librarians serving Young Adults and Children" <pubyac@prairienet.org>
Sent: Sunday, September 28, 2003 2:02 PM
Subject: PUBYAC digest 1227
PUBYAC Digest 1227
Topics covered in this issue include:
1) HIT: computer usage in children's room (long)
by "ehobson" <ehobson@ansernet.rcls.org>
2) Ancient Egypt
by "Kim Dolce" <kdolce@co.volusia.fl.us>
3) Book Vendors
by "Maria Trinca" <mtrinca@ansernet.rcls.org>
4) instructions for evaluating internet resources
by Jennifer Baker <jbaker93711@yahoo.com>
5) Re: mpaa ratings & community standards of decency
by "Melissa MacLeod" <mmacleod@sailsinc.org>
6) Re: mpaa ratings & community standards of decency
by seanps@george.net
7) RE: Harry Potter -Spanish Edition
by "Tatar, Becky" <bltata@aurora.lib.il.us>
8) Re: Research paper
by Lorie O'Donnell <Lodonnell@midyork.org>
9) Stumper
by Pteet@aol.com
10) Thanks! Re: video policy
by jmaskell@sover.net
11) Re: Programming Space name
by "Mary Voors" <Mvoors@acpl.lib.in.us>
12) Board Book Displays
by Sue Jones <sjones@ci.pleasanton.ca.us>
13) Re: rights and choices
by seanps@george.net
14) Children's Department Manager opening
by Susan Stonesifer <stonesis@hclibrary.org>
15) Oct. program ideas?
by "Diana Cook" <dcook@rpl.regina.sk.ca>
16) Re: mpaa ratings & community standards of decency
by seanps@george.net
17) Teen Programmes
by "Jess and John Dafoe" <jdafoe@telus.net>
18) stumper
by "Patricia Hull" <phull@slco.lib.ut.us>
19) More on Alternative Funding for Libraries
by Stephen Coffman <coffmanfyi@earthlink.net>
----------------------------
From: "ehobson" < ehobson@ansernet.rcls.org>
To: < PUBYAC@prairienet.org>
Sent: Sunday, September 28, 2003 1:06 PM
Subject: HIT: computer usage in children's room (long)
My apologies for the lapse time in posting this hit, but I was gratified to
know I wasn't alone in this situation.
Elizabeth Hobson
LIU Palmer School MSLIS student & Information Specialist
Nyack Library Children's Room
Nyack, NY
We have a variation of this problem, in that we have two terminals here in
Children's that have Internet access and actually have CD-ROM's loaded on
them that are suitable for younger kids to play. (we also have two Internet
access terminals with no CD-ROM's, so technically kids could get to games on
them as well).
We approach it from two angles - #1 children are not to be left unattended.
So the first response will be, "Are you here with your mom or dad? Oh,
you're here with your nanny? Let's go let her know you need some help."
This
response lets the child know they should be checking with their responsible
adult, and when we talk to the adult, lets the adult know they are
responsible for knowing if the child they brought needs help. #2 if the
computer freezes up (happens with some of the games), we go ahead and
restart it. We do not provide instructions on how to play the game - not
even for the very young ones. We will help them get to the game (start the
CD-ROM, find the game address), but we just tell them that "lots of kids
come in and play, but I don't know how to play this game myself". The kids
do very well with this response, and usually just plug ahead themselves and
work on it. If an adult questions why we have a CD-ROM loaded that we don't
know how to play (see, you're ahead with Internet games - they definitely
are not your responsibility to know how to play), we tell them that we
provide the CD-ROMS because patrons have indicated they enjoy them, but we
do not have time to sit down and play the games. This logic will work with
Internet games, also - just as we don't have time and unfortunately) don't
get paid to read every book in the library, we also don't have time and
don't get paid to work through every game on the Internet.
I realize, writing this, that it all sounds rather harsh. We are always
pleasant and use smiles when we talk with patrons about this - so far no one
has been offended with our answers.
Good luck!
Leslie Hauschildt
Head, Children's Services
Evergreen Library, Jefferson County Public Library
Hi--we also have two computers (well, only one right now,
technically, as one is being replaced) in out kids department. We
clearly state that we are NOT available to assist with the computers.
Parents must remain with young children, and we do not provide
instruction. We allow children 12 and under to use the kids
computers. We also have two teen computers for those 13-18--no
adults allowed. Parents uncomfortable with the teens being
unsupervised may supervise their kids at the 8 adult terminals.
Linette Ivanovitch
YA Librarian
Missoula Public Library
Missoulla, MT
Our children's room has one computer for patrons and one for staff. Our main
room upstairs has four patron access computers. Our philosophy is that
computer games are in no way necessary to a child's upbringing - they are a
luxury and if their parents wish them to have this luxury they, not we,
should provide them. Therefore our policy is that all our patrons may not
use games, IM's, or chat rooms. The children's room computer is for research
only, the adult ones for research and e-mail. They are limited to 30 minutes
per day, which is flexible if we're not busy.
We have had some patrons question this, especially if they are used to a
library that allows games or if they are avid game addicts, but we haven't
backed down. One storytime mother told me her friend prefers another library
in our system. It seems this other library allows games and it was on this
alone that she based her preference. Imagine choosing your library based on
who offers the best computer games. We don't miss her.
Peg Siebert
Blodgett Library
We have a very similar problem and have yet to come up with a good
solution. I hope you will post any responses you get!
Thanks,
Mary
Mary R. Voors
mvoors@acpl.lib.in.us
Children's Services manager
Allen County Public Library
200 East Berry
Fort Wayne, IN 46802
--
Elizabeth Hobson
Information Specialist
"Good judgment comes from experience. Experience comes from bad
judgment."
Mark Twain
--
----------------------------
From: "Kim Dolce" < kdolce@co.volusia.fl.us>
To: < pubyac@prairienet.org>
Sent: Sunday, September 28, 2003 1:16 PM
Subject: Ancient Egypt
Hello;
I have a homeschool mother who is looking for a good historical novel set in
ancient Egypt for her 7th grader. I've tried Genreflecting for Teens and What do
Young Adults Read Next, but didn't find too much. Any suggestions would be
appreciated!
Thanks,
Kim E. Dolce
Port Orange Regional Library
Port Orange, FL 32129
kdolce@co.volusia.fl.us
----------------------------
From: "Maria Trinca" < mtrinca@ansernet.rcls.org>
To: < pubyac@prairienet.org>
Sent: Sunday, September 28, 2003 1:18 PM
Subject: Book Vendors
Dear Colleagues,
I am looking at the possibility of using new (and/or) different book vendors
for next year.
What vendor do use/and recommend , or not recommend?
I am specifically interested in your experiences
regarding (a)returns , (b)cancellations, (c)back
orders {when the status changes from BO to cancelled} ; (d)turn-around time
for invoices and
(e)electronic services provided by the vendor.
My primary interest is looking at a vendor that has
a substantial fiction, non-fiction juvenile inventory, my secondary
interest, juvenile materials
in large print, foreign language, and multicultural
materials.
Please reply to : mtrinca@rcls.org
Thanks in advance for your information....
Maria Trinca
Head of Children's Services
Middletown Thrall Library
11-19 Depot St.
Middletown, New York 10940
Phone: 845.341.5470
Email: mtrinca@rcls.org
Fax: 845.341.5494
----------------------------
From: "Jennifer Baker" < jbaker93711@yahoo.com>
To: < pubyac@prairienet.org>
Sent: Sunday, September 28, 2003 1:23 PM
Subject: instructions for evaluating internet resources
if any of you have information you use for instructing
patrons on how to evaluated internet websites i would
love to see a copy. i'm doing a class next thursday
and need some support materials.
please email to jennifer.baker@fresnolibrary.org
or if it's only in print i'd appreciate a fax also:
559-488-1971 (attn: jennifer baker)
thanks so much!
~j.
=====
~jenniferbaker
fresno co. public library
"I may not be an explorer or an adventurer or a treasure seeker or a gun
fighter Mr. O' Connell, but I am proud of what I am." "And what is
that?" "I
am a librarian!"
~ Evelyn, The Mummy
__________________________________
----------------------------
From: "Melissa MacLeod" < mmacleod@sailsinc.org>
To: < pubyac@prairienet.org>
Sent: Sunday, September 28, 2003 1:26 PM
Subject: Re: mpaa ratings & community standards of decency
Thank goodness we can "what if" when policies that slide toward
censorship
and restricted access are considered. I would not be able to abide by child
cards that blocked access to certain materials. Besides, it wouldn't prevent
them from browsing all sections in the library or bookstores so all it would
do would be to lend power to the parents who don't want to supervise their
own children and take one more step toward regulation of information, which
something we should all be fundamentally opposed to.
----------------------------
From: < seanps@george.net>
To: < mmacleod@sailsinc.org>
Sent: Sunday, September 28, 2003 1:27 PM
Subject: Re: mpaa ratings & community standards of decency
Yes Melissa, I agree. Thank goodness we can "what if"
any policy that we deem objectionable, and eventually
come to a decision on what best serves the community.
Thank goodness also that anyone who decides not to
abide by what the majority chooses does not have to
retain membership in the organization. I also agree
that blocking the check-out of certain materials would
not prevent browsing of those items but, as we have
already said, there is no easy solution to the problem
of children's access to appropriate vs. inappropriate
materials.
I must disagree with your last few lines though, in
which you claim that any conceivable child card block
would only "lend power to the parents who don't want to
supervise their own children and take one more step
toward regulation of information, which is something we
should all be fundamentally opposed to." Just because a
mechanism or tool can be abused doesn't mean that it
necessarily will be in every situation. I could easily
"what if" a variety of situations in which a child card
block could be used constructively by a parent who does
in fact want to supervise their children but is
physically unable to be with their child every minute
of every day. After all, most children get out of
school every day before their parents get off of work.
Furthermore, I am opposed to saying what anyone should
or shouldn't be "fundamentally opposed to."
(Ironically, that would verge on regulating others'
opinions.) I know several librarians, and
non-librarians for that matter, who would say that
parents should in fact "regulate information" for their
children to some degree. That does not mean that those
people would support the government (or library)
regulating all information for all children, and a
child card block is much more like the former than the
latter.
--Sean
On Fri, 26 Sep 2003 11:15:52 -0400, "Melissa MacLeod"
wrote:
>
> Thank goodness we can "what if" when policies that
> slide toward censorship
> and restricted access are considered. I would not be
> able to abide by child
> cards that blocked access to certain materials.
> Besides, it wouldn't prevent
> them from browsing all sections in the library or
> bookstores so all it would
> do would be to lend power to the parents who don't
want
> to supervise their
> own children and take one more step toward regulation
> of information, which
> something we should all be fundamentally opposed to.
<><><><><><><>
Sean P. S. George
----------------------------
From: "Tatar, Becky" < bltata@aurora.lib.il.us>
To: < pubyac@prairienet.org>
Sent: Sunday, September 28, 2003 1:29 PM
Subject: RE: Harry Potter -Spanish Edition
If I remember correctly, when I asked on Reformanet list this summer about
this, I think it was the rep from Lectorum who said it wouldn't be out until
sometime in 2004, between January and May. Also, for anyone that's
interested, I saw somewhere that the German edition is just being released.
Becky Tatar
Unit Head, Periodicals, Audiovisual
Aurora Public Library
1 E. Benton Street
Aurora, IL 60505
PHONE: 630-264-4100
FAX: 630-896-3209
www.aurora.lib.il.us
E-mail: bltata@aurora.lib.il.us
----------------------------
From: "Lorie O'Donnell" < Lodonnell@midyork.org>
To: < draekan58@hotmail.com>
Sent: Sunday, September 28, 2003 1:33 PM
Subject: Re: Research paper
For several reasons, adults should definitely be allowed in the Children's
Room.
1. Children's caretakers are adults. They have to be able to select items
for the children in their care, even if the children are not with them.
2. College students are adults. They have to be allowed to utilize the
resources for their classes and projects (i.e. Reading, education, child
care majors)
3. Age discrimination.
4. Some adults are reading at children's levels.
Lorie
Amy Newcomb said:
> I'm conductiong research to write an Issues paper for my Library Science
> class and my topic is: Should adults be allowed iin to the children's
> section of the library?
>
> I'd appreciate any links to articles, or personal experiences I could use
in
> writng my paper.
>
> I can be reached at draekan58@hotmail.com
>
> If you have a personal experience to relate, please let me know who you
are
> so I can put you in my citations.
>
> Thank you,
>
> Amy Newcomb
>
> _________________________________________________________________
> Instant message in style with MSN Messenger 6.0. Download it now FREE!
> http://msnmessenger-download.com
>
>
Lorie J. O'Donnell
Children's Librarian
Jervis Public Library
Rome, NY 13440
lodonnell@midyork.org
--
"Lead me not into temptation (I can find the way
myself)."
-- Anonymous
----------------------------
From: < Pteet@aol.com>
To: < PUBYAC@prairienet.org>
Sent: Sunday, September 28, 2003 1:43 PM
Subject: Stumper
A high school student is looking for a contemporary King Arthur story. A
young man, who doesn't know he is really King Arthur, lives with his father,
who
used to be the caretaker of a great estate. Spurred by some crisis or other,
Merlin arrives and informs the young man of his true destiny.
Ring any bells?
Thanks so much,
Elizabeth Bluemle
*******************
----------------------------
From: < jmaskell@sover.net>
To: < pubyac@prairienet.org>
Sent: Sunday, September 28, 2003 1:49 PM
Subject: Thanks! Re: video policy
Thanks so much to everyone who responded to my question regarding video
check-
out policies and censorship!
I'm still battling this one out and with all of the information you sent I
hope
that in the near future children will have equal access to library
materials.
If anyone is interested in a compilation of the information please email me
off-
list and I'll forward it to you.
~Sam Maskell, Youth Services Library
*******************************
Rockingham Free Public Library
65 Westminster Street
Bellows Falls, VT 05101
802.463.4270
*******************************
----------------------------
From: "Mary Voors" < Mvoors@acpl.lib.in.us>
To: < pubyac@prairienet.org>
Sent: Sunday, September 28, 2003 1:50 PM
Subject: Re: Programming Space name
Thanks to everyone who responded to my request for room suggestions! I
was asked to post suggestions received to the list, so here goes:
Activity Room -3
Community Room
Fun Spot
Community Room
Playroom -
MPR - Multi-Purpose Room
Children's Activity Room - 2
Program Room
Activity Center
Gathering
Gathering Room
Group Place
Adventure Place
Adventure Room
Sharing Spot
Word Arcade
Activity Space - 3
Activities Room
Activity Room - 2
Big Room for Special Library Events
Big Room
Room for Library Programs
Meeting Room
Arts, Crafts, Story and More Room
Story Room
More Room
The Program Room - 2
ORIGINAL REQUEST:
We are in the midst of a Library Renovation. In order to begin looking
at signage, one of the many things we are considering is what we
should
call different spaces within our Children's Services department. I am
looking for suggestions on what to call the large room in which we'll
have everything from lapsits, to preschool storytimes, to puppet
shows,
to after-school crafts, to presentations for homeschooling families,
and
more.
What do you call your Programming Space? Any ideas on naming this room
would be most appreciated.
***********************************
Thanks again for all your suggestions!
Mary
----------------------------
From: "Sue Jones" < sjones@ci.pleasanton.ca.us>
To: < pubyac@prairienet.org>
Sent: Sunday, September 28, 2003 1:50 PM
Subject: Board Book Displays
Hello Theresa,
If you have the room and the money, Gressco LTD has some darling large
animal multi-media displays. We have one of their alligators for our board
books and darn if our BB's don't have the highest level of circulation in
the entire children's collection! Its toddler-high and extremely well-made.
Besides th alligator, they also have a purple hippo and a higher elephant
book display. I can tell you that the kids make a bee-line for it!
You can see them at www.gresscoltd.com
<http://www.gresscoltd.com>
and
enter "large animal multimedia displayers" in the search box or call
1-800-345-3480.
These aren't cheap, but we've had our alligator for 3 years and its
weathered mightly rough treatment.
My supervisor tells me that they can be ordered less expensively through
Ross McDonald here in our neck of the woods, ( www.rossmcdonald.com
<http://www.rossmcdonaldco.com>
) (925) 455-1635.
Good luck
Sue Jones
Pleasanton Library, CA
sjones@ci.pleasanton.ca.us
<mailto:sjones@ci.pleasanton.ca.us>
----------------------------
From: < seanps@george.net>
To: < Bonita.Kale@euclidlibrary.org>
Sent: Sunday, September 28, 2003 1:54 PM
Subject: Re: rights and choices
Bonita writes:
> It's my impression that rights inhere in the
> individual, not the community.
> The individual holds those rights specifically
> -against- the community which
> might might wish to outlaw (or possibly kill) him.
=======
I see duality by which, in addition to the individual
rights you cite, communities also have collective
rights to determine what behavior is lawful for their
community. Such rights guard against an individual
possibly killing others in the community. Optimally,
the rights of the individual vs. those of the community
hold each other in balance.
To apply that to the original issue though, I do agree
that individuals have rights. One such right is that of
a parent to choose what is appropriate for their child,
regardless of what others think might or might not be
appropriate. When individuals come together in a
community, such as to form a library system that serves
the population, that community has the collective right
to choose the parameters by which that institution
(i.e., the library system) will function. That of
course does not preclude the individual from exercising
his/her rights in opposition to any decision the
collective may make.
I believe that many individual parents see it as their
right to determine what their children do or don't
check out from the library. Many parents might simply
hold their child's libary card, so that the child could
not check-out anything without the parent being
present. Other parents might simply give the child a
library card and never pay attention to what the child
checks-out. There is also obviously a spectrum of other
possibilities, all of which are the right of the
individual parent to decide. If the local library
system has gone through a legitimate policy-making
process to create the option of a children's card that
would restrict check-out privileges to certain classes
of items, then each individual parent would have the
right to choose whether to use that option or not. One
parent's right to make that decision would not infringe
on the rights of other parents.
In light of your previous e-mail, asking if I would be
bothered by one patron (a parent) choosing what could
be checked-out by another patron (that parent's child),
the obvious follow-up question would be, "what about
the rights of the child?" I do believe that children
have rights but, since many rights come with attendant
responsibilities, I believe that parents can and should
selectively override their children's rights until the
child assumes the corresponding responsibilities. I
don't always agree with the decisions that I see other
parents making, and I'm sure they don't always agree
with my decisions, but I don't believe that children
should be allowed to raise themselves.
--Sean
<><><><><><><>
Sean P. S. George
----------------------------
From: "Susan Stonesifer" < stonesis@hclibrary.org>
To: < PUBYAC@prairienet.org>
Sent: Sunday, September 28, 2003 1:56 PM
Subject: Children's Department Manager opening
Howard County Library
Partners in Education
Why do people love their jobs at HOWARD COUNTY LIBRARY? Because we are
a first-rate, dynamic organization that stands for "excellence in
education." Ranked in the top 10 nationally for quality and service,
Howard County Library offers a friendly, collaborative work environment
with a generous benefits package which includes 14 paid holidays. Join
our team to find out why 95% of Howard County residents have Library
cards and why two million people visit us each year to check out five
million items.
CHILDREN'S LIBRARIAN - GLENWOOD BRANCH LIBRARY. Salary starts at
$35,367.00 pa. Desire lively, energetic person to fill leadership
position in the children's department of our newest branch library.
Located in a delightful country setting in picturesque western Howard
County, Maryland, this position places you at the children's reference
desk working with children from birth through sixth grade. Extensive
knowledge of children's materials and programming is essential. Duties
will include reference and reader's advisory services, program planning
and presentation, collection development and assisting customers of all
ages with materials and equipment. Supervisory experience as well as an
M.L.S. are required.
Please visit our web site at www.HCLibrary.org
for specific details.
DEADLINE: Applications must be received in Administration by October 9,
2003. Application available at all HCL branches and at
http://www.HCLibrary.org.
EEO/M/F/D Howard County Library,
Administration, 6600 Cradlerock Way, Columbia, MD 21045.
--
Susan L. Stonesifer
Branch Manager, Glenwood Library
Howard County (MD) Library
2350 Rt. 97, Cooksville, MD 21723
410/313-5580 410/313-5575 (fax)
stonesis@hclibrary.org
----------------------------
From: "Diana Cook" < dcook@rpl.regina.sk.ca>
To: " Pubyac@Prairienet.
Org" <pubyac@prairienet.org>
Sent: Sunday, September 28, 2003 1:57 PM
Subject: Oct. program ideas?
Hello, everyone! I'm wondering if anyone has any good program ideas for the
following:
I'm doing an Anansi program and I would like to do some kind of craft for
school age kids
and I'm doing a "Junior Science" program for ages 7-10 entitled
"Creepy
Spooky Science". We were intending to do something with dry ice, but I have
since discovered that is not an option. I have been doing Junior Science
for about 5 years and usually have no trouble, but I'm in a position where
we are short a staff person, and my brain just can't seem to focus on
anything at all for these programs...!
So if anyone would like to share some ideas with me, I would be grateful.
It's not that I'm too lazy to do my own research, it's just that you guys
have been a terrific resource in the past, so I thought I would ask before I
get truly desperate...!
Thanks a million,
Diana Cook
dcook@reginalibrary.ca
----------------------------
From: < seanps@george.net>
To: < mmacleod@sailsinc.org>
Sent: Sunday, September 28, 2003 1:58 PM
Subject: Re: mpaa ratings & community standards of decency
I will certainly concede that the Library Bill of
Rights is a strong argument against setting up an
automated child card block. I still maintain the
sovereignty of any given community/library system to
ultimately make their own decision on the matter. For
better or worse, the Library Bill of Rights does not
carry the weight of law, nor do all librarians
necessarily subscribe to all of ALA's proclamations.
I happen to agree with most of ALA's tenets myself but
I do not abdicate my right to disagree when I see fit,
and I hope nobody else does either. If my disagreement
with the organization ever reaches a "critical mass," I
will either work from within to effect a change in the
organization or dissociate myself from the group. I do
not however, expect that point to come in the
foreseeable future.
Please understand that I am not arguing in favor of
child card blocks but rather that such a system can be
readily seen as letting parents choose a customized
library service for their own individual child, which
is a far cry from letting any one parent choose that
type of service for all children.
I support your right to your opinion but I also stand
by my own assessment. Ultimately I think we are just
going to have to agree to disagree on this.
--Sean
On Fri, 26 Sep 2003 15:20:34 -0400, "Melissa MacLeod"
wrote:
>
> Library Bill of Rights
<snip>
> I believe that line V includes "abridged" along with
> "denied" and also
> "age," which leads me to reiterate that all librarians
> should be
> "fundamentally opposed" to cards that restrict access
> to material.
<><><><><><><>
Sean P. S. George
----------------------------
From: "Jess and John Dafoe" < jdafoe@telus.net>
To: < pubyac@prairienet.org>
Sent: Sunday, September 28, 2003 1:59 PM
Subject: Teen Programmes
I had a terrific time at our teen programme this month so I thought that =
I would share.
We purchased 4 pieces of very thin plywood each about the size of a =
large bulletin board and primed them with white latex. Then we penciled =
in 4 different Picasso like drawings (Cubism). We invited the teens to =
come and paint. They worked 4 or 5 to a board and the results were =
breathtakingly beautiful! We didn't show them the originals until they =
were finished, not wanting to stifle their creativity and they had a lot =
of fun comparing their work with Picasso's own. We finished up with =
sundaes. Each of the 18 participants even brought their parents down =
after to show off the creations. We will be displaying the pannels in =
the YA section and in the teen room.
Always looking for "cool" programmes for youth, so drop me a line if
you =
have one too.
jdafoe@telus.net
Jess Dafoe
Children's Services
Terrace Public Library
Canada
----------------------------
From: "Patricia Hull" < phull@slco.lib.ut.us>
To: < pubyac@prairienet.org>
Sent: Sunday, September 28, 2003 2:01 PM
Subject: stumper
This is a tough one . It is a picture book that has a boarder with a
storyline about a mouse playing the violin. The main story is maybe
about a musician writing music. We vaguely remember the mouse looking
over the boarder at the man writing?? The art is similar to Jan Brett.
It is not Mole Music Or Berlioz the bear. Any help would be
appreciated. Please contact me at phull@slco.lib.ut.us.
Thanks in
advance.
----------------------------
From: "Stephen Coffman" < coffmanfyi@earthlink.net>
To: < pubyac@prairienet.org>
Sent: Sunday, September 28, 2003 2:02 PM
Subject: More on Alternative Funding for Libraries
Good Afternoon You All
First off, just want to let you know that the response to upcoming LearningTimes
Webinar on Exploring Alternative Funding Sources for Schools and Libraries has
been very strong --- which either indicates there is a powerful interest in
investigating new revenue sources for schools and libraries --- or there's a
whole lot of you lining up to throw brickbats --- I guess we'll just have to
wait and find out on October 2nd. However, the great thing about Webinars is
that no matter how many hundreds of you register, there is always room for one
more --- so if you're interested in exploring alternative funding models for
libraries --- or if you think it's the nuttiest idea since OCLC sued The Library
Hotel --- be sure to logon to the free LearningTimes Webcast Alternative Funding
Sources for Public Schools and Libraries. The webcast will take place on October
2, 2003 at 3pm EDT/7pm GMT. For more information and registration for this FREE
webcast, log-on to http://www.libraryconference.com/freewebcast.shtml.
Here are a few more recent developments of note for those interested in
diversifying library revenues and exploring alternative funding strategies:
o The Library Community Foundation just released the results of an in-depth
year-long project to study fundraising in Illinois libraries. In general, the
report found a "deep disconnect in the library psyche when it comes to
fundraising." Stephen Daniels the Chair of the Library Community Foundation
Board said that the research showed that "almost everybody agreed that
public libraries need to diversify their revenue base to stay viable (over 85%
of the respondents agreed that the future viability of libraries depended on
diversifying revenue sources -- SC)" yet very few had "made the link
to fundraising, and fewer still fewer still had written any kind of a
fundraising plan." The study found that most library fundraising was
fragmented and centered on sporadic special events like book sales and that most
librarians felt a high degree of discomfort soliciting charitable support from
their constituents and that most were woefully unprepared to do so since those
skills are not generally taught in library school. So there's clearly a lot of
work to be done here, but the good news is that so many librarians now recognize
that future of the library depends on diversifying revenue sources and not being
so entirely dependent on tax dollars --- now we just need to develop some
effective tools and strategies to help us achieve that. Full details are
available on the project Website IL Libraries Becoming Fundraisers at http://www.librarycommunityfoundation.org/lbf/graphs/graph5.shtml.
o The Internet Librarian Conference is sponsoring a special full-conference
evening plenary session called Saving Ourselves: Alternative or Adventuresome
Funding Strategies from 7:30-9:00pm on Tuesday, November 4th at the Internet
Librarian Conference in Monterey, CA. The program will feature a panel of
presenters on all sides of the issue including: Caroline Punches, Director of
Development for the San Jose State University Library, Helen Kennedy and Jim
Lewis CFRE of Lewis / Kennedy Associates a long-time fundraising consultancy to
public radio, libraries, and other non-profits, Stephen Slade, Development
Director for Santa Cruz public radio station KUSP, Barbara Quint, Editor,
Searcher Magazine and ardent opponent of alternative funding strategies, Steve
Coffman, an ardent proponent of new funding strategies and VP, Product
Development, LSSI, and Rebecca Jones of Dysart & Jones Associates, the
ever-patient moderator. For further information on the program and the
conference, please see the Internet Librarian Website at http://www.infotoday.com/il2003/tuesday.htm.
And, by the way, if you are at all interested in alternative funding, there
could be few better places to explore it than Monterey, CA in November. Look
forward to seeing you all there.
o Alternative funding strategies are not just for public libraries, in fact
academic and major research libraries have been focusing on fundraising and
development for some time now -- and, of course, they have an excellent model to
follow since many major public and private universities are now raising
significant percentages of their operating budgets through contributions, gifts,
bequests, memberships, sponsorships and other sources of non-tax revenue. Their
libraries are beginning to follow suit and for an excellent example of what one
library has done, check out the UC Santa Cruz Libraries Development Office page
at http://library.ucsc.edu/development
--- they have been particularly successful raising funds through endowed
collections---which is a strategy that could work successfully for any library
--- publics included. The academic and research library fundraisers even have
their own organization --- it's called ALADN (Academic Library Advancement and
Development Network) and they've been getting together for an Annual Conference
every year since 1995, and you will find many interesting presentations from
past conferences on their Web site at http://www.library.arizona.edu/aladn
. They also sponsor the LIBDEV listserv --- subscription information at http://www.library.arizona.edu/aladn/libdev1.html
Finally, I'd like to take a moment to address a few of the objections that some
have been raised on the listservs over the past few weeks:
o Objection #1: The NPR model is about running libraries solely on donations and
pledge drives. We've already tried that and it will never work.
Answer: Public radio does not run its operations solely on donations or pledge
drives --- and I'm not suggesting that libraries do that either. What public
radio has learned to do is to effectively exploit every source of funding
available to them including tax revenue (from state, federal and local sources),
listener memberships, and underwriting and sponsorships. Technically the model
is called plural funding since the revenue comes from many sources, and it's not
just used by public broadcasting --- it's used virtually every major and minor
cultural and educational institution in our society --- including museums,
colleges and universities, zoos, orchestras, science centers (and I could keep
on listing for a long time here) --- except for libraries. And if the Illinois
study cited above is right, and the future vitality of libraries does lie in
diversifying our revenue base, then it is high-time we started learning how to
do it.
o Objection #2: A recent Washington Post article "Public TV Learns to Do
Without"(http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A10749-2003Sep14.html)
says that revenue for public television is declining --- therefore libraries
should not seek to diversify their funding.
Answer: Those that read the article found that funding for public television has
been made up of a "patchwork of revenue sources including pledge drives,
taxes, and sponsorships." Traditionally, the article goes on the
"system's strength has been its diversity: When one stream of contributions
dried up, another flowed." Now, however, all sources were declining .. and
the primary culprit is the declining audience for public television programming
because of competition from very similar offerings on commercial cable channels.
The article also notes that Public TV's faltering financial picture stands in
"stark contrast to public radio stations, which are on sounder footing.
While many public radio stations are also losing state and institutional
funding, they're attracting bigger audiences, which traditionally have supplied
about half of a radio station's operating budget." Now, if you believe that
the audience for public libraries is drying up, as it appears to be for public
television, then I say to you that we've got a problem, no matter what type of
funding we are relying on --- but, if you believe, as I believe, that the
audience for public libraries is growing and has the potential to expand well
beyond where it is today --- then I think the pubic radio model has a lot to
teach us.
o Objection #3: Steve Coffman is writing about it, Steve Coffman is with LSSI,
therefore alternative funding is an LSSI thing and we shouldn't pay any
attention to it.
Answer: First off, I've been interested in alternative funding for a very long
time long before I joined LSSI. In fact, here is an article I wrote on it for
Searcher back in January 2000, (http://www.infotoday.com/searcher/jan00/coffman.htm)
when I was still bona fide government employee on the staff of the County of Los
Angeles Public Library. Now, you bet, we are interested in the NPR or plural
funding model at LSSI --- and the reason is that we are interested in providing
the communities we work for with the best library service possible --- and that
means more books, longer hours, more programs, better pay, and nicer facilities
--- and a stable and diversified revenue base that can grow and expand as the
audience for library services grows and expands --- just like public radio. We
would hope that you all share those goals for your library, no matter who you
work for and you certainly don't have to be an LSSI library to accomplish it.
Many libraries have already started down the path to diversified funding (as you
can see when you take a look ALADN website) and many others want to .. if the
results of the Illinois study are any indication. So please get over this evil
empire fixation and examine the issue on its merits.
Yours,
SC
End of PUBYAC Digest 1227
|